With the winding down of days left in this year’s legislative session, things are ramping up. Schools this legislative session have seen it all—in 131 different education-related fixes, reforms, budget issues, and pet projects. Interestingly, 19 have been abandoned and only 8 have passed, leaving 104 left to see their fate before the 2011 General Session of the 59th Legislature adjourns sine die. That’s just 10 days, folks.
Apparently, this might not be enough micromanaging or political intervention for the Legislature because yesterday Senator Howard Stephenson unveiled a bill to make the State School Board an extension of the political parties. Yes, if this bill passes, school decision makers will be forced to run through a political party, be elected in a partisan election, and become embroiled with all the politics that comes with it. So much for making decisions based solely on what’s good for school children!
We can only hope that others in the Legislature consider the following survey information:
- The poll shows 78% favor keeping the process non-partisan rather than getting nominations through political parties. (Feb. 2011 Utah Policy Daily, Opinionology Poll)
- 66% oppose forcing candidates for the Utah State Board of Education to run through a political party which would require going through primaries and conventions in order to get nominated. (Nov. 2011 Dan Jones Survey)
- 67% of those who took the survey indicated that their public schools “probably are not” or “definitely are not” adequately funded in order to provide a quality education. (Nov. 2011 Dan Jones Survey)
- Respondents identified themselves by party: 51% Republican, 15% Democrat, and 22% Independent. (Nov. 2011 Dan Jones Survey)
There has been much debate and publicity on the idea of partisan vs. non-partisan school boards in the past couple of months. As you can see, the more citizens have become educated on the issue, the more sure they are that partisan school boards do not serve the children of the state.
There are many, many reasons not to pass a partisan school board bill. No one political party captures all of the issues in public education nor has all the remedies for its many challenges. Public education should not be restricted by operating inside of the parameters of a political party or of its party leader(s). Partisan politics, even well-intended, tends to be uneven and subject to the whims of lawmakers. Schools should not have to brace for new administrations or new majorities or new representatives each election cycle. Children and teachers need continuity and stability, even as they work to innovate and improve. Local leadership provides local accessibility to all of Utah’s citizens. Let’s not have school board members become “beholden” to politicians; let’s keep them accountable to their neighbors and local communities.
Contact your Senator and Representative today, and tell them to vote NO on SB224 Partisan School Board Elections. Find out who your Senator and Representative are here.
